Monday, August 25, 2008

Why I'M not a fan of Cass Sunstein

Before taking issue with Kathy G's specific attack on Cass Sunstein, I noted that I'm also not a fan of Sunstein. I guess I should explain why. Sunstein is an excellent administrative law scholar (which is where he made his name), and a decent, if somewhat inconsistent, constitutional law scholar. My problem is with Sunstein's law and economics work. He's prolific in the law and economics field, where he's considered one of the leading "liberal" scholars. As I've noted before, the large majority of law and economics scholarship is pure Hackonomics, and is basically worthless even for theoretical purposes. Instead of teaching the basic neoclassical model as the building block of economic analysis, to be refined and adjusted, sometimes dramatically, based on the specific context, law and economics teaches the basic neoclassical model as the final product of economics—apply basic model to area of law; get answer; repeat as necessary. Sunstein seems to have only two ways of reaching his so-called "liberal" conclusions in his law and economics work: he either plugs the findings of behavioral economics into the basic law and economics model, or he mangles basic economic analysis (as John Quiggin caught him doing yet again). Either way, he accepts that the absurdly simplistic and reductionist law and economics model is the appropriate model, with the only assumption potentially in need of tweaking being perfect rationality. Believe it or not, you don't have to be a behavioral economist to reject the Chicago School, or its even-more-simplistic cousin, law and economics. Behavioral economics is a useful field, but its central findings are far from the only, or even most effective, attacks on the law and economics model. Many of the same "liberal" conclusions could reached through a proper application of economics, rather than the Happy Meal version used by most law and economics scholars. As the estimable Dani Rodrik puts it:

[T]he tendency of many economists to offer advice based on simple rules of thumb, regardless of context (privatize this, liberalize that), is a dergoation rather than a proper application of neoclassical economic principles.
Sadly, as much as law and economics scholars bother me, most of them are actually better at economic analysis than Sunstein....and that's saying something! And this just reinforces the belief in the law and economics field that economic analysis doesn't generally support liberal positions. (To be fair, not all law and economics scholars are disingenuous armchair economists, and done correctly, law and economics scholarship can be very intellectually stimulating. Ian Ayres and Lee Anne Fennell are a cut above everyone else; their work is tremendous. Bob Ellickson is also very good. I don't know what everyone sees in Henry E. Smith's work though.)

7 comments:

James said...

I'm a big fan of Randy Picker, who is also at U of C. Among other things, he applies industrial organization to anti-trust, network industry, and intellectual property questions. He's not at all like the caricature of law & econ types.

dte said...

c9 online goldlife is not measured by the number of breaths we take, but by the moments that take our breath away buy c9 gold, ability may get you to the top, but it takes character to keep you there cheap c9 gold.

dte said...

If you lose your way, your forever friend guides you and cheers you on Diablo iii Gold, if you turn and walk away, your forever friend follows Buy Diablo iii Gold, your forever friend gets you through the hard times, the sad times, and the confused times Cheap Diablo iii Gold.

PENNY STOCK INVESTMENTS said...

Excellent

Fire Ball said...

Đang tìm siêu thị điện máy cũ ở tphcm? Nếu bạn đang cần máy lạnh cũ tiết kiệm điện, máy giặt nội địa nhật hcm, hay tìm nơi mua bán tủ lạnh cũ tphcm thì hãy ghé qua thằng ghờm shop nhé. Đến với chúng tôi bạn sẽ được phục vụ chu đáo tận tình. Chúng tôi sẽ giải đáp cho bạn thắc mắc bạn gặp phải... Nếu có nhu cầu cần đến điện máy cũ hay đã qua sử dụng, hãy nhớ đến chúng tôi.

Bạn cần cập nhật các kiến thức như fa là gì, thẻ ghi nợ là gì, deep web là gì hãy ghé qua chuyên mục kiến thức tổng hợp để bổ sung kiến thức cho mình nhé.

master seo said...

Prediksi Leicester vs Manchester United 29 November 2015– Pada lanjutan liga inggris pekan ke 14 akan mempertemukan Prediksi Leicester vs Manchester United

master seo said...

Cobaqq.Com Agen Judi Poker Online Dan Bandar Domino Duit Asli Terpercaya