Wednesday, June 29, 2011

SIFIs and Capitalism

Thomas Hoenig garnered a bunch of headlines the other day for, as usual, making a provocative and hyperbolic statement about financial reform. Discussing the concept of systemically important financial institutions (known as SIFIs), Hoenig said:

“I suggest that the problem with SIFIs is they are fundamentally inconsistent with capitalism. They are inherently destabilizing to global markets and detrimental to world growth. So long as the concept of a SIFI exists, and there are institutions so powerful and considered so important that they require special support and different rules, the future of capitalism is at risk and our market economy is in peril.”
Oh no! The future of capitalism itself! Not surprisingly, Hoenig doesn’t explain this bizarre assertion; he just makes the provocative statement and moves on, which is par for the course for him. Of course, anyone who understands this issue beyond the level of superficial sound-bites knows that Hoenig’s claim is ill-informed nonsense.

It’s true that SIFIs are subject to “different rules” — they’re subject to more stringent regulations, and to more conservative capital requirements. They’re subject to a prompt corrective action (PCA) regime, liquidity requirements, resolution plans, enhanced public disclosures, and additional stress tests. (I know what you’re thinking: “How did the big banks convince Congress to shower them with all these goodies? Is there no end to the corruption?”)

SIFIs are also likely (though not automatically) subject to the Title II resolution authority, which makes it easier for SIFIs to fail. The Title II resolution authority mirrors the FDIC’s resolution authority for commercial banks, except Title II is more stringent — e.g., unlike the resolution authority for commercial banks, Title II doesn’t permit “open-bank assistance” for SIFIs. And back during the nationalization debate, Hoenig was absolutely convinced that the resolution authority could successfully wind-down even the largest, most complex financial institutions.

So if SIFIs can in fact fail just like any other bank under the new resolution authority (which Hoenig has said they can), and the only difference between SIFIs and other banks is that SIFIs are subject to more stringent regulations, how exactly are SIFIs threatening the future of capitalism? The answer, of course, is that they’re not. This is just Hoenig looking to get in the papers by saying something mean about the Big Banks.

Just remember that Hoenig is also the guy who’s been warning about runaway inflation for the past two years, and who thinks the Fed shouldn’t “bring [unemployment] down too rapidly.” So take him seriously at your own peril.

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

PCA has been a bank capital evaluating regime for all banks and savings institutions since the 1989 FIRREA act. It is not a different requirement for SIFIs. Looks like SIFIs will have to keep an enhanced capital cushion but what the hell, repos are the ultimate "hot deposits."

Steve said...

I think Hoenig's recent point is that the mere existence of a SIFI is a problem. There shouldn't need to be a class of banks that require special support and rules (even *more stringent* rules), and even under special resoultion, they are much more troubling to wind-down.

TBTF implied too big to exist. Without rehashing EoC vs. Yves, does SIFI fix all of those risks to satisfaction? No, it does not.

Should the U.S. taxpayer backstop, or even allow, a global payments network attached to cross-guaranteed U.S. and foreign deposit banks attached to an investment bank attached to proprietary hedge fund attached to a massive derivatives creation & clearing operation? I would argue no, and certainly no discount window access. Bank = bank only.

Q: What are EoC's thoughts on reinstating Glass-Steagall?

Y = X said...

I'm not an economist and know very little about the true workings of the financial system. It appears from my perspective that very large corporations and banks have become too large to be controlled by a single country. The defect of globalization is the lack of a supranational governing structure.

Chrevron is nice when it does business in the U.S. but not in Ecuador. When capital can be moved easily from country to country then threat of large corporation A relocating to another country becomes real. Governments will compete to become the most business friendly (least regulation).

Capitalism appears to be a bad system when negative externalities aren't properly dealt with. Right now they don't appear to be properly dealt with.

I don't think Dodd-Frank will do much because it's only as good as the enforcers. The top leaders in our financial system all come from top banks. It's a revolving door. Spend a few years at Treasury and then a few at some large institution.

Well, this is how I see things but I'm not in the know. From my perspective we need a new system.

Main Street Muse said...

Had no idea that TBTF is now known as SIFI - interesting moniker for banks that are now even bigger than the TBTF institutions that crashed the economy in 2008.

Seems to me that SRI-FI would be better - a reminder that these banks are "systemically risky" financial institutions; let's place the emphasis on the risks they pose, not their "importance."

When all is said and done (and we have not reached the point of being all said and done on this issue yet, as I understand it), SIFIs may indeed be able to fail - enter bankruptcy - without collapsing the economy - but in that the systemic risk they pose remains high enough to warrant special treatment, I still do not understand how such a failure won't be like crying "fire" in a crowded theater. Panic is hard to legislate around, and bankers facing a run on their bank have been shown to be even more emotionally fragile than Brittany Spears.

And seeing that the heads of SIFIs move easily between the banks and positions of power in Washington, enhancing their "importance" even more, I remain skeptical of the ability of those in power to stop SIFIs from throwing the economy of a cliff once again.

Cheap Runescape Gold said...

hardly any in regards to the accurate processes in the financial system. Seems like coming from my point of view that will huge firms and also financial institutions are getting to be too big to get manipulated with a single country. The trouble associated with globalization will be the insufficient a supranational ruling composition.

Buy Runescape Gold
RS Gold

Anonymous said...

almost noDiablo 3 items regarding the precise functions in the financial system. Looks like via my point of view that could large companies and also banking companies are increasingly becoming too large to acquire manipulated using a one nation. The effort regarding globalization may be the inadequateCheapest wow gold some sort of supranational lording it over composition.

GM MDI said...

This device supplies engine control and monitors the function and performance of your various auto launch x431 gx3 price parts like the chassis, body, and other automobile accessories such as the manage network in the automobile.

sapık ahmet said...

Free sex videos xhamster hd aways way.

obd2s online store said...

I got these codes and i replaced my catalytic converter and both front and rear sensors and muffler and piping so nec24c64 basically the whole exhaust system and i still got these code so i replaced the sensors again and still get the codes and i have a rough idle where the car shakes and revs and has a hard time.gm tech2 diagnostic scanner shifting up to 30mph. what else could be the problem? i cant find any answers. It's a John Deere? So I researched it to find out it's the O2 bank 2 Sensor 1 but confliting info I've found doesn't tell me which one it is. Is it upstream of the cat or downstream. Is it the passenger side or drivers side? Amy help would be greatful.

murs dask said...

yemek tarifleri
ekol hoca
android market
twitter aç

WLKgames said...

At a matter of fact, some people think there having a negative buy guild wars 2 gold impact on the PC WOW game industry as a whole.

wuyu said...

Bringing the epic world of The Elder Scrolls games to the online cheap wow gold universe will prove to be a rare challenge. NBCNews.com's Todd gw2 gold Kenreck reports.

Cahaya Mandiri said...


It is amazing posting and incredible work, It has suitable information, I presently wanted to say that you have really so motivating and very informative post. Thanks for wonderful posting
tips cara agar cepat hamil l CARA BELAJAR BAHASA INGGRIS l the best acne treatment l how to lose weight fast easy
margahayuland l BELAJAR BISNIS ONLINE l tips cepat hamil l how to get rid of acne home remedies l
home remedies for acne l how to cure acne fast l
baju batik modern l toko sepatu online l grosir jam tangan online l
jual jam tangan l toko jam tangan murah peluang usaha online l is acne no more for you l how to get rid of acne naturally
how to clear acne l cure acne naturally
best natural remedies for acne l acne no more l tempat belajar bisnis online
peluang usaha rumahan l cara mendapatkan uang dari internet
makanan sehat agar cepat hamil l penyebab tidak bisa hamil lcara agar cepat hamil


Visio 2010 said...

In Microsoft Visio Standard 2010 Download, you can simplify planning with inactive and activetasks to perform what-if analysis.
Visio Professional 2010 Download helps business and creative professionals communicate and collaborate more effectively and securely with virtually anyone, anywhere. Unify a wide range of content in a single organized PDF Portfolio. Collaborate through electronic document reviews. Create and manage dynamic forms. And help protect sensitive information.
Whether you are creating a diagram from scratch or modifying an existing one, Microsoft Visio 2010 Download helps you add and align shapes easily and accurately, with features such as the Quick Shapes Mini Toolbar, enhanced dynamic grid, page Auto Size, and automatic alignment and layout adjustment.

bell said...

Joyo pedalsI really enjoy looking through on this website ,Simulate Amp Pedals it has got superb articles . "The great secret of power is never to will to do more than you can accomplish.OverDrive Pedals

The All-American Rejects said...

A man may usually be Runescape Gold Sale known by the books he reads Runescape Gold as well as by the company he keeps; for there is a companionship of Runescape GP books as well as of men; and one should always live in the best company, whether it be of books or of men.

The All-American Rejects said...

You laugh at me for being gw2 gold different, but I laugh at you for being the same. Experience gw2 gold is a hard teacher because she gives the test first, the lesson gw2 gold afterwards. Ability may get you to the top, but it takes character to keep you there.

PENNY STOCK INVESTMENTS said...

Great