Seriously, Jesse Eisinger needs to stop writing about the Volcker Rule, because he has absolutely no idea what he’s talking about. His latest article makes a number of egregious errors, but I want to focus on the one that’s most demonstrably untrue. Eisinger writes: (emphasis mine)

The Congressional authors of the Volcker Rule worried about this very thing [i.e., the potential to move prop trading into the bank’s treasury operation], and you can trace their concerns through their drafts. The original language of the rule had a broad exception: banks couldn’t trade for their own account, but they could hedge to mitigate their risks.

The authors quickly realized that the exemption was absurdly broad. After moving these businesses to other divisions, banks would then argue that their bets were either market-making activities or simply hedges that offset risks.
...
So Congress tightened the language. It wrote that the hedges had to be specific. When the Dodd-Frank financial reform law came out, the Volcker Rule provision defined “risk mitigating activities” as trades that were “designed to reduce the specific risks to the banking entity in connection with and related to such positions, contracts, or other holdings.” No macro-hedging, only micro-hedging. That is the will of Congress.
This is patently untrue on so many different levels. For one thing, Eisinger conveniently omits the first part of the hedging exemption, which explicitly allows portfolio hedging. But we’ll get to that. First, let’s do something that Eisinger clearly didn’t do — actually trace the hedging exemption through Congress’s drafts.

Here, in chronological order, are Congress’s main drafts of the hedging exemption in the Volcker Rule (with the key language that was added to each version in red):

Draft 1 — PROP Trading Act (S. 3098), introduced by Senators Merkley and Levin on March 10, 2010:
“(C) Risk-mitigating hedging activities.”
Draft 2SA 3931, introduced by Merkley and Levin on May 10, 2010:
“(C) Risk-mitigating hedging activities designed to reduce risks to the banking entity or nonbank financial company.”
Draft 3SA 4101, introduced by Merkley and Levin on May 18, 2010:
“(C) Risk-mitigating hedging activities designed to reduce the specific risks to a banking entity or nonbank financial company supervised by the Board.”
Draft 4 (Final Language) — Final conference report (H. Rept. 111-517), which was signed into law on July 21, 2010:
“(C) Risk-mitigating hedging activities in connection with and related to individual or aggregated positions, contracts, or other holdings of a banking entity that are designed to reduce the specific risks to the banking entity in connection with and related to such positions, contracts, or other holdings.”
Look at the difference between the last two drafts — as you can see, contra Eisinger, all of the changes in the final version substantially broadened the language of the hedging exemption.

The key is the language that Eisinger conveniently omitted in his article, which specifies that banks’ hedging can relate to “aggregated positions, contracts, or other holdings” — i.e., portfolio hedging. Note also that the final version clarifies that “specific risks” does not mean specific positions, because the “specific risks” that banks must be hedging can also relate to “aggregated positions, contracts, or other holdings.” The interest rate risk in a bank’s mortgage portfolio, for instance, is a “specific risk” that relates to aggregated positions. That’s what portfolio hedging is — it’s hedging the risks of the bank’s aggregate positions.

Eisinger clearly does not understand this distinction — he claims, falsely, that Congress “wrote that the hedges had to be specific.” Not true. Again, it’s the risks that have to be specific, and those risks can relate to aggregate positions.

This is exactly what Congress intended. All of this language about “aggregated positions” was added between Draft 3 and Draft 4 specifically to ensure that portfolio hedging would be allowed under the Volcker Rule. Indeed, there’s no other logical explanation for why Congress added the language about hedging “aggregated positions” between Draft 3 and Draft 4.

Thus, as you can see, it was clearly “the will of Congress” that portfolio hedging be allowed under the Volcker Rule.

So why did Eisinger claim that portfolio hedging is prohibited under the statute when it’s so clearly allowed? Probably because it allows him to self-righteously criticize both the banks and the regulators, and to present himself as far too knowledgeable and savvy to be fooled by all this fancy talk about “portfolio hedging.” (This kind of posturing is becoming increasingly common.)

But the reality is that portfolio hedging is 100% allowed by the Volcker Rule’s statutory language, and this is exactly what Congress intended — and anyone who tells you otherwise doesn’t know what they’re talking about.

41 comments:

Vasos Panagiotopoulos said...

Instead of a waivable binary Volcker Rule, they should use a Taylor-like Rule that changes with leverage squared, volatility and inversely GNP (the SDE is (L-1) dr + L d var). A numerical rule is harder to waive, and can fit into Basel regulations for risk capital.

sewa mobil jakarta said...

Nice article, thanks for the information.

John@PGISelfDirected said...

Definitely something that could only come from a certified expert on the field. Thanks for the info.

farmland investments said...

I agree with Vasos above, makes perfect sense.

Anonymous said...

Rather than a waivable binary Volcker Guideline, Cheap RS Goldthey will make use of a Taylor-like Tip of which improvements together with control squared, unpredictability along with inversely GNP (the actual SDE is actually (L-1) generate + T deborah var). Any exact concept can be more difficult for you to waive,Buy WOW Gold and can squeeze into Basel restrictions regarding threat cash.

Monika said...

24very nice blog Pune Escorts

analytical instruments supplier said...

I have read it your post nice with perfect knowledge and bookmarked it on with my friends who may like it

final exam

http://getfinalexam.blogspot.com

foxfol said...

If you play RuneScape game you may know that runescape goldaccount is important to you.
Reading here you need to need to know how to protect runescape gold Account. You'd much better use a lengthy and complicate username and password. And do not abuse passwords anyplace else. Don't download hacks on your laptop or computer simply because they may be all hoaxes. When you have a plan that will cause you to millions of runescape gold would you give it out One hundred percent totally free? You'll not! So do not think anybody who gives out the program totally free.

Chinese Fashion said...

Keep away from physical contact together with the opposite sex. An unlikely motion like a non-committal elbow brush may turn off the trader. Also, don't move your hands quite generally for gesturing factors.

Anonymous said...

Your prediction is very accurate, and the Congress knows what to do...
cheapest wow gold

QUALITY STOCKS UNDER 5 DOLLARS said...

When it comes to wall street banksters it seems like rules are designed to be broken as far as their concerned.

murs dask said...

yemek tarifleri
ekol hoca
android market
twitter aç

cheap gw2 gold said...

Instead of a waivable binary Volcker Rule, they should use a Taylor-like Rule that changes with leverage squared, volatility and inversely GNP (the SDE is (L-1) dr + L d var). A numerical rule is harder to waive, and can fit into Basel regulations for risk capital. GW2 Gold

where to buy rs accounts said...

I’ve been exploring for a little bit for any high-quality articles or blog posts on this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this web site. sell runescape accounts I’m happy to convey that I have an incredibly good uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I most certainly will make sure to don’t forget this website and give it a glance on a constant basis.

Can you feel the love tonight said...

It takes strength to be truthful when a lie would be more convenient D3 Gold, it takes strength to be polite to someone when that person has been rude to you Buy D3 Gold, it takes strength to persist in the face of obstacles, when it would be much easier to simply give up Cheap D3 Gold.

GuildWars2Items said...

It takes strength to do what must be done when the work is unpleasant and uncomfortable [url=http://scarletbladegold.com]scarlet blade gold[/url], It takes strength to persist in the face of obstacles, when it would be much easier to simply give up [url=www.gameim.com/product/Scarlet_Blade_Gold.html]scarlet blade gold[/url], It takes strength to be polite to someone when that person has been rude to you[url=http://scarletbladegold.com]scarlet blade gold[/url].

GuildWars2Items said...

Diablo 3 Gold someone who makes you believe that there really is good in the world, someone who makes you laugh until you can't stop Buy Diablo 3 Gold, someone who changes your life just by being part of it Cheap Diablo 3 Gold, this is Forever Friendship

GuildWars2Items said...

One meets its destiny on the road he takes to avoid it Cheap C9 Gold, If I could rearrange the alphabet, I'd put Y and I together c9 gold, People who are serious about the relation are moody as they have devoted a lot that makes them worry about gains and losses c9 online gold

dte said...

I will spare no efforts in doing things WOW Power Leveling, the master of a single trade can support a family. The master of seven trades cannot support himself wow gold, No one has ever been or will ever be strong enough to take our freedom away from us Sell WOW Gold.

dte said...

It takes strength to build for the future Diablo 3 Power Leveling, it takes strength to be polite to someone when that person has been rude to you Diablo 3 PowerLeveling, it takes strength to build for the future Diablo iii PowerLeveling.

Adobe Acrobat 9 Download said...

Store, share, and reuse business process diagrams and subprocesses through Visio 2010 integration with SharePoint 2010 Process Repository.
Acrobat 9 Pro helps business and creative professionals communicate and collaborate more effectively and securely with virtually anyone, anywhere. Unify a wide range of content in a single organized PDF Portfolio. Collaborate through electronic document reviews. Create and manage dynamic forms. And help protect sensitive information.

Vivian Salvatore said...

Diablo 3 Gold Inform us how we like to do each of those, and that we may solution your own question.As an example, Cheap GW2 Gold do you want to deal destruction with miraculous as well as bodily signifies?

Cahaya Mandiri said...


It is amazing posting and incredible work, It has suitable information, I presently wanted to say that you have really so motivating and very informative post. Thanks for wonderful posting
tips cara agar cepat hamil l CARA BELAJAR BAHASA INGGRIS l the best acne treatment l how to lose weight fast easy
margahayuland l BELAJAR BISNIS ONLINE l tips cepat hamil l how to get rid of acne home remedies l
home remedies for acne l how to cure acne fast l
baju batik modern l toko sepatu online l grosir jam tangan online l
jual jam tangan l toko jam tangan murah peluang usaha online l is acne no more for you l how to get rid of acne naturally
how to clear acne l cure acne naturally
best natural remedies for acne l acne no more l tempat belajar bisnis online
peluang usaha rumahan l cara mendapatkan uang dari internet
makanan sehat agar cepat hamil l penyebab tidak bisa hamil lcara agar cepat hamil


ERICS said...

This week's show is called Testing because it's what we did. We tested going back to a live format. It's a bit different than the previous live shows we used to do, as we're a bit more focused on recording the actual show. However, we still managed to work in a few chat channel comments, and took some time afterwards to talk with everyone that hung out with us.


------------------
cheap wow gold
rs gold

bryann said...

Awesome! Its genuinely awesome article, I have got much clear idea regarding from this piece of writing.
uae offshore company incorporation

buy runescape gold said...

This week's display is known as Examining because it's what we did. We examined going returning to a stay structure. It's a bit different than the past events we used to do, as we're a bit more targeted on documenting the real display. However, we still handled to perform in a few discuss route feedback, and took a while afterwards to discuss with everyone that installed out with us..

rs gold
WOW Gold Kaufen
Bade & Soul Gold

Buckley Carlucci said...

On the way two new sets of Double buy runescape gold cheap Fine. Double Fine, makers of the next Broken Age, have announced that they will release two new games platform funded IndieFund.Se The identity of these two new projects, which will surely follow the premises of cheapest runescape gold titles that are in preparation as Age or Massive mentioned Chalice.M s Broken News: Double Fine, Broken Age

cara membuat toko online said...

That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this. This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great.soal-soal cpns ll Asian Brain ll cara cepat hamil ll Tips cepat hamil ll Busana Muslimah Modern ll Toko Baju Muslimah Modern ll rahasia cara memutihkan wajah

ibaikaltablet said...

Thanks for the post that was so very informative, I’ve learned a lot. Keep up the good work.Galaxy 3 cases I need more information about it can you do that? Thanks.

Wei Liu said...

We have the complete work of this artist on dvd,Iphone 4s case Joao.

The All-American Rejects said...

Stray birds of summer come to my window to sing GW2 Gold Guide and fly away. And yellow leaves of autumn, which Buy GW2 Gold Guide have no songs, flutter and fall there Guild Wars 2 Guide with a sign.

The All-American Rejects said...

I believe that we are not real GW2 Gold Guide social workers. We may be doing social work in the Buy GW2 Gold Guide eyes of the people, but we are really contemplatives in the heart of Guild Wars 2 Guide the world.

zoyi330 said...

Awesome. Awesome. Amazing!!Currently, I am ninja costume looking for ideas for making throughput noticeable with the wall.Fantastic!

jimmy wilson said...

Exceptional post I adore the document; appreciate how you explained all things, you are carrying out a great job lots of other people as you through that sort of educational websites supply understanding to be able to all of us related to lots of things. When i examine some other exciting websites from a websites and also I'm so much interested along with your blogging knowledge, My partner and i in addition did start to generate post and also this kind debate truly assist us out and about. My partner and i by now bookmarked your webpage and contributed ones internet websites to be able to our acquaintances besides myself yet every one of them just like ones blogging skills, expect a person write a lot more exciting websites similar to this 1 as well as enjoy for the upcoming sites.

Jimmy Wilson-Resident Evil Jacket Leon

Shannon Baker said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Shannon Baker said...

This article is mind blowing. When I read this article, I enjoyed.

book publicity

anu jain said...

Mumbai Escorts help make a night exciting as well as loving Independent Escorts Mumbai
our own Organization is accessible throughout the India then one may get all of them in
Mumbai Escorts
Escorts In Mumbai
Mumbai Escorts Service
Escorts Service In Mumbai
Mumbai Indepndent Escorts
Indepndent Escorts In Mumbai
Mumbai Female Escorts
Female Escorts Mumbai
Mumbai Call Girls
Call Girls In Mumbai

anu jain said...

Hello! I am Sonal Malik. I’m presented hi class Vip Mumbai Escort girl Red Light City
Mumbai I'm a high fair-haired, with long legs, projected and tight legs In High Class
Mumbai Escorts
Escorts In Mumbai
Mumbai Escorts Service
Escorts Service In Mumbai
Mumbai Indepndent Escorts
Indepndent Escorts In Mumbai
Mumbai Female Escorts
Female Escorts Mumbai
Mumbai Call Girls
Call Girls In Mumbai

anu jain said...

I have a VIP Escorts Service Mumbai promoter Team where different prices are appropriate
course natural charges are aspect of the deal importance you protect the natural Escort
Mumbai Escorts
Escorts In Mumbai
Mumbai Escorts Service
Escorts Service In Mumbai
Mumbai Indepndent Escorts
Indepndent Escorts In Mumbai
Mumbai Female Escorts
Female Escorts Mumbai
Mumbai Call Girls
Call Girls In Mumbai

QUALITY STOCKS UNDER 5 DOLLARS said...

Great blog

Seth said...

I totally agree with Vasos. I am reading this at work shaking my head...