Wednesday, July 30, 2008

On Posner

Richard Posner has always been a polarizing intellectual. But I must admit, I'm still extremely conflicted about Posner. On the one hand, he literally wrote the book on Law & Economics. He has long served as the unofficial leader of the so-called Law & Economics movement—a field which bothers me to no end, and with which I'm immensely disappointed. He has written countless "law and economics of ____" law review articles, many of which can only be described as pseudo-economics. These articles basically amount to a quick-and-dirty application of the most simplistic neoclassical economic model to different areas of law. As a result, they're extremely misleading, both about the proper economic analysis of those areas of law, and about the nature of economics. On the other hand, he occasionally churns out a brilliant and thoughtful work. His new book, How Judges Think, is just such a work. In contrast to his more grating pronouncements about the dominance of Law & Economics, his tone in How Judges Think is measured, and his analysis is rigorous. He doesn't make any sweeping claims about how judges think. Instead, he examines in great detail the competing theories of how judges think, evaluates the (somewhat limited) empirical evidence, and notes that each theory's explanatory power is highly context-specific. It's not for the faint-of-heart, but it's a richly rewarding book in the end. Which brings me back to his role in the Law & Economics movement. Don't get me wrong, law students desperately need to be introduced to economic concepts, and Law & Economics has vastly improved the quality of the legal academy. As I've noted before, when I went to law school, I was absolutely stunned by my first-year classmates' lack of basic economic knowledge. But instead of teaching the basic neoclassical model as the building block of economics, to be refined and adjusted (sometimes dramatically) based on the specific context, Law & Economics tends to teach the basic neoclassical model as the final product of economics. Undergraduate economics classes are usually fraught with warnings about the limitations of the basic neoclassical model (or at least they're supposed to be). Those warnings are virtually non-existent in the Law & Economics literature. As a result, Law & Economics tends to attract adherents who are committed to economics as an ideology rather than as a method of analysis. Somewhat surprisingly, law professors who have been converted to the Law & Economics movement tend to be the worst breed of play-economists—and their articles tend to represent Hackonomics of the highest order. For too many law professors, being exposed to Law & Economics is like taking Arrogance Pills. But despite my many problems with the Law & Economics movement, I'm inclined to cut Posner some slack. He paved the way for the teaching of economics in law schools, and it wasn't always easy. Posner's emphasis on economics faced fierce resistance from the other schools of legal thought, which sometimes took the form of thinly-veiled personal attacks in prestigious law reviews. To see just how much Posner—despite his distortions of economic analysis—has improved the quality of legal scholarship, all you need to do is read one of Posner's most prominent "opponents," Robin West. This is actually the abstract of a lengthy and well-known article attacking Posner's law & economics, written by West, and published in the Harvard Law Review of all places:

Law-and-economics theorist Richard Posner has argued that principles of consent support wealth maximization as a rule of judicial decisionmaking. According to Posner, wealth-maximizing consensual transactions are morally desirable because they promote both well-being and autonomy. In this Article, Professor West draws on Franz Kakfa's depictions of human motivation to dispute the empirical basis of both justificatory prongs of Posner's thesis. Kafka's characters, she argues, suggest that when individuals consent to transactions, they often do so because of a desire to submit to authority, and not to maximize well-being or autonomy. Thus, Professor West concludes, Posner's identification of consent as the moral justification of wealth maximization rests on an inadequate view of human motivation.
To refute the empirical basis of Posner's economic analysis of law, West relied on . . . fictional stories! That's the equivalent of saying, "your analysis of human motivation is wrong because I can make up a story where humans have different motivations." These were the kinds of "intellectuals" Posner had to deal with for a long time. So I can understand if he had to dig his heels in a little too much in his advocacy of the basic neoclassical economic model.



Great story on posner.

Trần Duy Thuận said...

Trần Duy Thuận Blog đang cần nhận gia công tại nhà. Ai có cần người nhận gia công tại nhà tphcm liên hệ mình nhé. Truy cập vào đặt vé máy bay giá rẻ vietjet để có thêm kinh nghiệm khi đi máy bay nhé.

mua thuoc tot said...

Collagen là thành phần giúp da chống lại quá trình lão hóa và giúp trẻ hóa làn da những thực phẩm chứa nhiều collagen sẽ giúp bạn dể dàng bổ sung collagen vào cơ thể.Mất ngủ hiện nay đang diễn ra một cách nhanh chóng , ở mọi lứa tuổi khác nhau , bị mất ngủ phải làm sao ? Bị mất ngủ nên dùng thuốc hoặc đến gặp bác sĩ điều trị. Cách làm kem trắng da không phải là khó , sau đây là công thức kem trộn trắng da toàn thân dể dàng và đơn giản , bạn có thể làm tại nhà. Trí nhở tốt là mon muốn của hầu hết mọi người , vậy làm thế nào để có trí nhớ tốt ? Có nhiều cách đơn giản giúp bạn làm được điều đó. Giảm cân hiện nay đang là một xu hướng của mọi người , đặc biệt là phái nữ. Để giảm cân cấp tốc 1 tuần không quá khó, nên có một chế độ tập luyện và ăn uống một cách khoa học và có lộ trình sẽ giảm cân được. Gan là bộ phận giúp cơ thể lóc các độc tốt torng cơ thể , uống gì mát gan đẹp da ? Có nhiều thức uống không chỉ giúp đẹp da mà còn giúp mát gan.

Fire Ball said...

Đang tìm siêu thị điện máy cũ ở tphcm? Nếu bạn đang cần máy lạnh cũ tiết kiệm điện, máy giặt nội địa nhật hcm, hay tìm nơi mua bán tủ lạnh cũ tphcm thì hãy ghé qua thằng ghờm shop nhé. Đến với chúng tôi bạn sẽ được phục vụ chu đáo tận tình. Chúng tôi sẽ giải đáp cho bạn thắc mắc bạn gặp phải... Nếu có nhu cầu cần đến điện máy cũ hay đã qua sử dụng, hãy nhớ đến chúng tôi.

Bạn cần cập nhật các kiến thức như fa là gì, thẻ ghi nợ là gì, deep web là gì hãy ghé qua chuyên mục kiến thức tổng hợp để bổ sung kiến thức cho mình nhé.

bamgosoocom said...

If you are going for most excellent contents like me, simply go to see
this site every day for the reason that it presents quality contents, thanks

Review my webpage::: 부산오피